San Francisco Chronicle, "NTSB to Set
Blame in Kentucky Comair Air Crash"
Government
staff investigating last summer's deadly Comair plane crash in Kentucky
recommended enhancements in airport taxiway markings and cockpit map
displays Thursday as a response to the crash. The National Transportation
Safety Board is deliberating the cause of the crash of Comair Flight
5191, which killed 49 of 50 people on board after the jet tried to depart
from the wrong runway -- a general
aviation strip too short for a proper takeoff. Although NTSB's five board
members were to vote on a cause later in the day, the NTSB's proposed
the airport changes earlier Thursday.
NTSB staff
concluded that the fact that the flight crew didn't have updated maps and
notices alerting them to construction that had changed the taxiway route
a week earlier was not a factor in the navigation error. Board member Deborah
Hersman, who was the lead investigator on scene, suggested there were numerous
causes -- nearly all of them human. "That's the
frustration of this accident -- no single cause, no single solution
and no 'aha' moment," Hersman said.
About 25 relatives of crash victims gathered at a hotel in downtown Lexington
on Thursday to watch a video link to the hearing. Melissa Byrd, whose brother,
Ryan, died in the crash, said it has been "a very long year" and
she didn't expect any surprises from the hearing. "Honestly, at this
point, we don't care who's to blame," Byrd said. Commuter airline
Comair has acknowledged at least some culpability. Pilots violated cockpit
rules about extraneous conversation as they were going through their preflight
checklist and may have been distracted as they steered the jet in the pre-dawn
darkness onto the wrong runway.
Unclear, however,
is whether anyone beyond Comair will share blame from the government. Comair
contends that the government itself -- specifically
the Federal Aviation Administration, which runs the control tower at Blue
Grass Airport -- also is partly responsible. At the time of the crash,
only one controller staffed the tower, despite an FAA directive that at
least two should keep watch.